871 Sagaponack Main St

Sagaponack, NY 11962

Half Bath
Single Family Home

Property Description

Click for NYS Housing Discrimination Disclosure Notice & Form

In the heart of historic Sagaponack, this authentic 2-acre compound 0.6+/- miles from the ocean consists of a meticulously maintained farmhouse along with four additional pre-existing, non-conforming structures, offering boundless opportunity for the creative mind. The property is steeped in history and was even previously owned by the Topping family. Originally built in the 1920's, the recently renovated and fenced-in 2.5-story farmhouse offers 4 bedrooms, 2 full and 1 half baths over 3,700+/- sq. ft. of living space. The home offers multiple seating and entertaining areas, along with a formal dining room, and three wood-burning fireplaces. The bucolic grounds feature a poured cement pool that is designed to stand the test of time, and is surrounded by a spacious brick patio, outdoor shower and a pool shed. What makes this property truly exceptional is the unprecedented amount of customizable space, including an additional 865+/- sq. ft. studio currently being utilized as an artist's studio, a 3,200+/- sq. ft. barn containing a recently renovated international squash court and gym, a 756+/- sq. ft. multipurpose structure with full bathroom, and a 2,955+/- sq. ft. barn that offers additional raw space with a large open loft area. These buildings all predate zoning and now offer nearly limitless potential for just about any residential use one can imagine. Some options these buildings can afford the future owner include a home office, gym/exercise room, indoor pickle ball court, dance/ballet studio, painting studio, sculpture studio, photography studio, music/recording studio, media room, game room, woodworking shop, automotive shop, vehicle/classic car storage, general storage, kids entertainment space, horse barn, or utilizing the blending of outdoor and indoor living for hosting a private gathering. Impossible to replicate under current Sagaponack zoning rules and regulations, the property exudes a rustic charm reminiscent of the origins of Sagaponack and transports you back to a simpler time. All while idyllically located south of the highway moments to Sagg Main and Gibson Beach, this Sagaponack farm estate is truly one-of-a-kind.
Show MoreShow Less


  • Interior
    3,700 Sq Ft.
  • Exterior
    2 Acres
  • Property Type
    Single Family Home
  • Year Built
  • MLS/Listing ID


  • Central Air Conditioning
  • Fireplace(s)
  • Gym
  • Pool
  • Storage
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • South of The Highway
  • Heated Pool
  • Home Office
Show MoreShow Less


  • Air Conditioning
  • Backyard
Show MoreShow Less